Sign In

Thought Thursdays

 Empires of the mind

2016-01-28 00:00
Frik Landman

TT14 frik.jpgWinston Churchill once said: “The empires of the future are the empires of the mind." 

Just by observing the rise of the knowledge worker and the battle for talent, Churchill’s comment intuitively resonates with me. For the moment, I won’t focus on the physicality of the brain. My interest, rather, lies in how we can responsibly cultivate this piece of problem-solving ‘equipment’, not merely to respond creatively to the condition of life for our own sake, but more especially so as to contribute to a better and more peaceful world for all. 

For now I wish to focus on the development of leadership minds in Africa. Consider for a moment the fact that we have the richest continent on the globe, given our natural resources, land mass, young population, etc. Now juxtapose all these wonderful assets with the state of our sociopolitical arena: our unsatisfactory rate of turning our resources into wealth for all, the mediocre quality of our institutional life, the poor quality of governance, etc. The leadership behaviours that engineered some of these unattractive results are clearly not governed by the kinds of minds and mind-sets we need to design and sculpt our future.

Consider the role of the empires of the mind when Peter Drucker states:

No century in recorded history has experienced so many social transformations and such radical ones as the twentieth century. They, I submit, may turn out to be the most significant events of this, our century, and its lasting legacy.​

With the world therefore becoming all the more VUCA, the leader-managers in our organisations are under pressure to keep shaping their minds, to keep their paradigms porous. How can we assist these leaders to discharge their leadership duties in the most responsible and sustainable way?

Henry Mintzberg, management development guru, acknowledges this challenge and suggests a way forward when he describes management as “a complex and challenging practice where art, science and craft meet”. In response to this insight and in an effort to influence and shape the empire of the mind, Jonathan Gosling and Henry Mintzberg developed an international programme focusing on five different managerial mind-sets, namely the reflective mind-set, the analytical mind-set, the worldly mind-set, the collaborative mind-set, and the action mind-set.

Taking a page from Gosling and Mintzberg, let’s also note some substantive research done by Howard Gardner, captured in his book Five Minds for the Future and appreciate what practical value it has for those who take the development of their minds seriously. Firstly, the development of the managerial mind will go nowhere in the absence of the first form of thought, i.e. discipline. It is imperative for managers to be able to think in a distinctive way, which in turn is a result of proper dedicated development and experience, the mastering of the things that make up the central theme of their profession as leader-managers. This surpasses having theoretical knowledge of management and leadership or even knowing “… seven steps to …”. Allow me to give an example: You may be able to play me a tune on a guitar, but this does not make you a guitarist. If you can communicate that you are a guitarist in only one way, playing one tune, very little of the discipline under discussion is at work. The moment you have mastered the guitar, you will be able to play any tune, and you will be able to communicate the essence of your guitarist profession in different ways and in different modes. You will be able to create novel sounds, use various techniques, tell stories with your instrument, play before an audience, etc. So it is with the disciplined managerial mind.

Our complex world actually requires more than that which Gosling and Mintzberg offers regarding the analytical mind. It needs a complementary form of thought that Gardner names the synthesising mind. Analysis has been a dominant form of thought in the Western world for centuries – the notion being that if we take anything apart and understand its parts, we understand the whole. This ‘ain’t gonna work’ in a VUCA world, which demands a systemic view of things. It requires not only knowing how a system works, but why it works and why it produces the results that it does. 

The relationships between the parts demands understanding. Russell Ackoff states:

The performance of the whole is never the performance of the parts taken separately, but is the product of the interactions, and therefore the main managerial idea introduced by systems thinking is that to manage a system successfully you must focus on the interactions of the parts rather than their behaviour taken separately.​​​

Many times we observe effective leaders synthesising by telling stories, or using metaphors of all kinds. 

 A third form of thought is to have the ability to express your discipline in more than one way. Consider Howard’s creative mind: The nature of the challenges our leaders face can never be tackled by the stock or standard thinking and methodologies of the past.  Elisabeth Dostal, for instance, points out: “[T]he logic of the problem is not the logic of the solution.” The creative mind emerges where Mintzberg’s assertion (where art, science and craft meet) happens. In this part of the empire there is dissatisfaction with how things are done, and the creative mind artfully crafts the same scene with a different medium and presents it in a new form in the hope for continuous progress. Such a mind is as disciplined and dedicated as that of a master artist.

I think that relationships resemble a continuous battle between cathexis (the bringing down of the walls of my identity and allowing the flowing in of another identity almost to the point of losing my own) and xenophobia (where the walls of my identity are so strong and impenetrable that they allow me to think and act as if others don’t have the right to exist, and that only I and my own have that right). This is where Gardner’s fourth form of thought resonates: the respectful mind. There is a case for us to discipline our minds and to acknowledge that others in their ‘otherness’, in their differentness, are not less than me and my own. To develop the empire of our mind, we seriously have to expose our minds to experiencing different forms of diversity in order to embrace the fact that being different is not equal to being flawed. This cuts far deeper than race and gender.

Peter Koestenbaum describes ethics as “being of service to others”. For this to happen, Gardner formulates the fifth form of thought needed for the future, the ethical mind. The manager with an ethically cultivated mind accepts excellence in work as a logical consequence of being of service to others. This completes the loop with the first form of thought, namely discipline, which is largely the motivation behind the ethical mind.

The development of the empire is a continuous imperative for those choosing to lead.


Frik Landman is the CEO of USB Executive Development (USB-ED)​. He is passionate about developing leaders who can make a meaningful contribution to the greater African community. His sentiments echo USB-ED's 2020 Vision: to develop managers who lead with wisdom and courage.

This is a good article and a must to read for all aspiring project managers and leaders alike. I particularly enjoyed the five different managerial mindsets which have been thoroughly elaborated and one can relate them to existing situations, particularly in the African context. As a prospective graduate of the USB, I am glad that I can relate myself to most of those forms of thought and principles which I intend to unequivocally apply to my work environment with pride. Again, that was a good piece of writing, Frik. We (as managers and leaders) need more of those, now and then, to recharge our managerial and leadership batteries to ethically govern and manage our continent"s natural resources for the betterment of all.
Posted by Felix Muyoba on 28-01-2016 9:36 AM
Why did you not speak out  when  SA was governed through white xenophobia,"....where the walls of my if others don't have the right to exist....'The NP suffered from xenophobia. Despite your excellent article on leadership, it is too little too late! The ANC is trying to reinvent the wheel through different platforms, they do not show  leadership in our complex society .Mr. Frik Landman, as a South African I am more disappointed in the white academia and intelligentsia  for not speaking out against the tyrannical rule of  the NP.May be you were too young at the time or too afraid. Thank you for the excellent article .Be more visible please. Write more.
Posted by Samuel Haas on 29-01-2016 1:46 PM
While appreciating the content of the article and the context around which it is written, the African continent still needs to address the real problem and should begin to take the bull by its horns. I share the same sentiments on the Leader-manager concepts, however, the real problem that faces Africa revolves around the African Question. While the West has managed to form strong alliances that has assisted their countries to move 50 years steps ahead, Africa continues to be divided and the results are clearly written in the Political, Socioeconomic and Developmental WALLS. I think it is time for true leaders to emerge from their various organizations and sculpt Africa for African. There is veracity in the view that the logic of our African Leadership challenge can no longer be the necessity for means to pursue the African Solution for the African Question. While we want to expand Education and build empires of the mind, it is, in my view, equally imperative to address the African Question through dealing with both the physical borders and those that have been instilled in our African minds, so we can truly claim "I AM AN AFRICAN". The concepts of Leader-managers should begin to assist the African continent to think ahead and move 50 years forward through strong alliances among African Countries themselves. In my view, until Africa unite to be a state that relies on Africa, the leader-manager concepts will remain among our wish lists and the writing on Political-socioeconomic Developmental WALL of Africa will be the same in the next century. The African economy requires drastic change in the leader-manager mindset of Africans. Africa Must Unite. 
Posted by Veli Steven Khoza on 01-02-2016 4:12 AM
Wonderful thoughts Frik! Yes, arts and craft of linking the science in the context is extremely important..and to shape this in right combination human values driven guiding management philosophy essential!  Mahatma Gandhi said “The world has enough for everyone's need, but not enough for everyone's greed.” Management education providers have an opportunity to shift the greed driven management development to human-driven leadership development!
Posted by Shiv Tripathi on 02-02-2016 7:34 PM


Email address:


1000 characters left

All comments are reviewed by the blog moderator before it is posted.
Africa; Leadership